CLEVELAND BROWNS
Cleveland Browns

Myles Garrett trade rumors spark after Browns hire Todd Monken as HC

Garrett had an MVP-level season as he broke the single-season sack record

Myles Garrett celebrates a sack against the Cincinnati Bengals.
Myles Garrett celebrates a sack against the Cincinnati Bengals.LaPresse

The Cleveland Browns have closed the chapter on one of the NFL's longest head coaching searches by hiring Todd Monken, the former Baltimore Ravens offensive coordinator.

While the decision resolves the leadership void at the top, it raises pressing questions about the future of the team's defensive identity.

Myles Garrett trade rumors spark after Browns hire Todd Monken as HC

Monken's hire signals an offensive shift, but it also casts uncertainty over defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz, whose tenure has been central to Cleveland's success over the past several seasons.

Related:

Ashley Bastock of Cleveland.com captured the potential fallout: "The ripple effect of Schwartz leaving could be incomprehensible."

Over the past three seasons, the Browns were among the league leaders in total yards allowed, and uniquely, they held opponents under 300 yards per game on average.

This defensive consistency has been critical to Cleveland's identity, allowing the offense to grow without carrying the full burden of wins.

Star players like Myles Garrett, Denzel Ward, and Grant Delpit have voiced strong support for Schwartz throughout the coaching search.

Owner Jimmy Haslam also underscored the coordinator's importance in public remarks, acknowledging the stabilizing role Schwartz has played since Kevin Stefanski's departure.

Despite these assurances, Cleveland opted for Monken, who brings a robust offensive background but lacks NFL head coaching experience.

A delicate balance between innovation and stability

Monken inherits a team that has leaned heavily on defense for stability and identity, which immediately frames one of his first challenges: whether he can maintain continuity on the defensive side while implementing his offensive vision.

Schwartz has reportedly informed his assistant coaches that he plans to depart following Monken's hire.

While Monken has the discretion to retain him, he holds full authority over staffing decisions. This unresolved tension will test Monken's leadership in his inaugural season.

"Monken has the authority to assemble his staff as he sees fit, and while he has expressed openness to retaining Schwartz, nothing is finalized," an NFL source noted.

The situation also raises questions about the team's star players, particularly Garrett, who has remained patient through previous coaching transitions.

Asking a franchise cornerstone to embrace another reset, especially if it risks losing the defensive architect he has supported, could challenge his patience and commitment.

"No one is publicly discussing a trade request, and Garrett's no trade clause protects him, but the warning signs are significant," an NFL analyst observed.

Losing Schwartz would not simply be a staffing change; it could destabilize a defense that has been Cleveland's most dependable asset.

The Browns now face a delicate balancing act: integrating Monken's offensive philosophy while retaining the defensive stability that has defined the team in recent years.

How the front office navigates this transition will likely determine not only the immediate trajectory of the Browns' season but also their long term identity as a contender in the AFC.

Cleveland BrownsShedeur Sanders reportedly convinced Todd Monken to become the new Head Coach of the Cleveland Browns
Cleveland BrownsWhy no one wants to coach the Cleveland Browns: 4 brutal rejections explained
Cleveland BrownsShedeur Sanders in trouble: Browns hire head coach who called team a "total mess"