NCAA
ncaa

Harsh criticism for Deion Sanders' Colorado Buffaloes: Is it time to walk away from the deal?

Viral spring game clips fuel backlash as fans question Buffaloes' physical readiness

Deion Sanders
Deion Sanders
Updated

The Colorado Buffaloes' spring game has triggered an unusually intense round of criticism, with analysts and casual viewers breaking down every visible detail of the team's performance and physical build. What is typically a low-stakes offseason showcase has instead become a viral moment of scrutiny.

In the modern college football landscape, even limited spring footage can quickly snowball into sweeping narratives about a program's direction.

As the team ran out of the tunnel at Folsom Field, clips spread rapidly across social platforms, setting off immediate reactions. Many viewers focused less on scheme or execution and more on the physical appearance of the roster.

The Colorado Buffaloes were widely described online as appearing undersized compared to other Power Four programs, with some critics suggesting they lacked the bulk typically associated with elite-level college football. While spring games are traditionally used for depth evaluation and installation of systems, this did not stop sweeping judgments from forming within hours.

Physical impressions spark debate over program strength

The reaction soon shifted toward broader questions about strength training and conditioning. Some critics even questioned whether the team is physically prepared for the demands of a full season in a competitive conference.

"I swear I am not saying this to slander them for fun or to be an ass. There are high school football teams that are bigger than Colorado," wrote one user on X.

Another wrote: "Middle schoolers looking swell. When does JV take the field?"

The Buffaloes do employ a dedicated strength staff led by Andreu Swasey, whose role is central to building size and durability across the roster. However, these types of assessments are rarely visible in a single scrimmage setting, where rotations are frequent and players are not typically in peak game-day form.

Head coach Deion Sanders continues to oversee a major roster transformation in Boulder, one that has included heavy personnel turnover and constant media focus.

His approach has brought unprecedented visibility to the program, but it has also increased the speed and intensity at which criticism develops. In this environment, even spring practices can become flashpoints for larger debates about long-term competitiveness and program identity.

Despite the negativity, there were still positive notes emerging from the game. Among them was discussion around young quarterback Julian Lewis, who has been mentioned as a potential cornerstone for the future. His presence has offered fans something to be optimistic about amid broader concerns about depth and physical development.

Spring game evaluations are often misleading when taken in isolation. Roster construction and system mastery evolve significantly between April and the start of the regular season.

As summer approaches, speculation will likely intensify, but clearer answers will only emerge once full-contact competition begins and the Buffaloes face real opponents under real conditions in the fall.

ncaa Dylan Raiola's weight puts him further behind Patrick Mahomes and sets off alarm bells in Oregon
ncaa Bill Belichick trades the sidelines for pom-poms as he supports girlfriend Jordon Hudson
ncaa Projected first-round NFL pick Brendan Sorsby enters rehab amid gambling probe