- MLB. Carlos Mendoza makes his intentions clear with Bo Bichette in his plan to bring the Mets back to life
- MLB. Carlos Mendoza can't hide his excitement after the Mets' signings
The New York Mets managed to add some shine to their MLB offseason, but none of it would have been possible without making a move that "terrified" people inside the organization.
While it's true they suffered major losses with the departures of Pete Alonso and Edwin Díaz, it was also vital to trade away a beloved Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers.
One thing became crystal clear over the last few months: no player was untouchable because GM David Stearns was willing to make whatever moves were necessary to take this Mets roster to another level.
Has Stearns' plan been successful?
At the very least, they succeeded in shedding Brandon Nimmo's contract, which still had more than $100 million owed over five years-a move that allows them to avoid having defensively challenged Mets outfielders.
According to MLB insider Joel Sherman, who appeared on Foul Territory, this trade was precisely the "key" transaction of the Mets offseason.
Sherman noted that there was genuine fear within the organization about having both Nimmo and Juan Soto in the outfield due to the potential defensive problems they could create, in addition to the complicated roster decisions required when using a designated hitter.
The motivation to move Nimmo also stemmed from his injury history throughout his career. The 32-year-old veteran has managed to play more than 150 games in each of the last four seasons, but his advancing age and a neck inflammation at the end of the season gave the New York Mets reason to believe he might not be able to continue performing at his peak.
"To play, and to play the way he plays... he breaks down at a higher level, but plays through it," he said. "So that was like the bad news within the good news."
The departure of Nimmo also allowed them to aggressively pursue Kyle Tucker in free agency-although they ultimately ended up with Bo Bichette-and with the addition of Semien in the infield, it's safe to say the Mets will become a significantly better defensive team.
The ultimate test will come at the start of the 2026 season, but especially during the development phase as they look to reverse the poor performance of 2025-when the Mets led the division for much of the year only to lose it and miss the MLB playoffs entirely.